Gelato Vs Printify for Print-on-demand: Which One is Better?

The battle of Gelato vs Printify is still a puzzle for many print-on-demand sellers. Feeling curious about which is the best? Let’s dive into this article with Teeinblue to discover now! From products, printing quality, pricing, production, shipping, and customer services, to the pros and cons of each company, this article covers all you need. Let’s get started with Teeinblue!

Gelato Vs Printify: a Quick Comparison

According to Grand View Research, Gelato and Printify are prominent players in the print-on-demand industry. With years of experience and impressive successes, both companies have established themselves as top-rated choices for selling personalized products.

Pros and Cons of Gelato

Gelato, a print-on-demand company based in Oslo, Norway, has been transforming the industry since 2007 with a team of over 400 people. Focusing on sustainability, it has produced 90% of its 10 million+ orders locally, reaching more than 5 billion customers.

Here are Gelato’s advantages:

Fast local order processing with an eco-friendly approach
Faster turnaround times, especially in the European market
A larger network of global fulfillment and shipping partners than Printify

Besides, it also has some limitations:

A narrower product catalog than Printify, with only 100+ offerings
Fewer integrations compared with Printify, with only 6 options

Pros and Cons of Printify

Since its establishment in 2015, Printify has built a team of 600 employees at its headquarters in Wilmington, Delaware, US. Over 8 million sellers have used its print-on-demand service to deliver $500M+ products to customers around the world.

Printify is known for its perks:

A wider product range of over 900 print-on-demand items
More affordable base costs for merchants
Various integrations with 10+ platforms

However, there are Printify’s drawbacks to consider.

Fewer suppliers for production and shipping
Slightly longer delivery when compared with Gelato

Gelato has been in the print-on-demand market longer than Printify

1. Gelato Vs Printify Products

Product range

Printify holds dominance over Gelato with a catalog 9 times larger. It offers over 900 items, compared to Gelato's 100+ products.

However, Gelato sets itself apart by specializing in eco-friendly products, adhering to strict safety standards, and using responsibly sourced materials. Its local production approach ensures saving costs, effort, and energy sources.

On the other hand, Printify focuses on diversity and affordability. Some unique products from Printify include swimwear, shoes, face masks, pet items, car accessories, kitchen accessories, and more. It regularly updates its catalog with trending and new products like beauty and coffee goods.

gelato vs printify print on demand product catalog

Printify outweighs Gelato with its extensive catalog

Product pricing

In terms of product cost, Printify offers a lower base and more price segments than Gelato. Print-on-demand sellers will find a wider array of options to sell with Printify.

Take a look at the detailed comparison table below to compare the prices of some print-on-demand products from Gelato vs Printify.

Products	Gelato	Printify
T-shirts	$6.29 - $27.19	$8.67 - $34.4
Hoodies	$19.06 - $74.55	$20.34 - $61.7
Canvas wall art	$9.28	$9.12 - 29.49
Mugs	$6.28 - $17.14	$4.4 - $19.37
Phone cases	$7.85 - $13.28	$8.96 - $13.34
Cards	$7.43 - $9.95	$3.96 - $14.55

2. Product Quality

Printing methods

Printify offers more printing methods than Gelato. While both companies utilize popular techniques like DTG and DTF, Printify provides additional options to cater to the different needs of customers.

Printify methods include:

DTG is a reasonable technique for printing t-shirts, hoodies, and tote bags.
DTF is more durable and well-suited for activewear or label neck.
AOP and sublimation methods are preferred for creating a smooth finish on clothes, shoes, and home decor items.
Sublimation and UV printing are best for drinkware.
Digital printing is ideal for paper-based products like canvas and postcards.

With Gelato, besides DTG and DTF, you can explore more unique product options with the embroidery method. This technique is trending for adding personalized stitching to t-shirts, sweatshirts, hoodies, and hats.

gelato vs printify for print on demand selling

DTG and DTF are popular printing techniques in print-on-demand

Printing quality

In general, both Gelato vs Printify received praise for high product quality. However, both companies utilize outsourced printing facilities, which may cause quality inconsistency between different partners. To ensure the final quality meets your expectations, you should place sample orders to test firsthand.

3. Production and Shipping

Each company has established a large network of global fulfillment and shipping partners. Notably, Gelato boasts faster turnaround times and a wider print network than Printify. Gelato is better in the European market, while Printify is highly rated in the US.

Have a glance at the following table comparing Gelato vs Printify fulfillment.

Feature	Gelato	Printify
Production & delivery time	In the US: 4-8 days In the EU: 4-6 days Other regions: 3 -14 days	Production: 2-7 business days Shipping time In the US: 2-8 days Other regions: 3-30 days
In-house factory	No facility	No facility
Partners	140+ production partners and 60+ logistics partners in 32 countries: US, Canada, UK, Germany, Australia, and New Zealand, etc.	90+ providers and 110+ printing locations across 12 countries: US, UK, Spain, Latvia, Canada, Australia, China, etc.

4. Integrations & Selling Tools

Gelato and Printify offer intuitive dashboards and mobile apps, along with various e-commerce integration options. While Gelato scores for its excellent tools, Printify excels in large integrations and an easy-to-use interface. Here are the outstanding features of each company to compare.

Gelato integrations and tools

6 e-commerce integrations, including Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, Squarespace, Wix, BigCommerce, and API to connect more apps.
Personalization studio for easy customization of designs on platforms like Etsy and Shopify.
Mockup Generator to showcase your print-on-demand products more engaging.
Price Navigator to monitor and adjust product prices for maximum profit.
Built-in analytics tools provide valuable data and insights to optimize business performance.
Design maker for creating eye-catching print-on-demand artwork with ease.
Gelato mobile app to keep track of print-on-demand stores easily.

Printify integrations and tools

10+ integrations, including Shopify, Etsy, Walmart, eBay, TikTok Shop, Wix, Squarespace, WooCommerce, PrestaShop, BigCommerce, and Printify API.
Free pop-up store for setting up a standalone store quickly.
Mockup creation with 900+ stunning mockups and AI Image Generator to enhance product visualization.
Shutterstock integration for accessing premium artwork or photos for just $0.99 per sale.
User-friendly dashboard to navigate, select products with sort filter, manage orders, and more.

gelato vs printify print on demand integration

Both companies provide integrations with popular sales platforms

5. Pricing Models

When it comes to subscriptions, Gelato and Printify offer free and paid plans. These flexible pricing cater to both print-on-demand starters and enterprises.

With the free plan, Printify provides more benefits for print-on-demand sellers.

Printify allows users to create up to 5 stores per account, whereas Gelato permits only 2 connected stores. Additionally, Printify's free plan offers access to almost all its functions.
Whereas Gelato imposes some limitations. For example, free Gelato accounts cannot use live rates or express shipping in Shopify. You also can’t include branded labels and packaging for posters.

For paid plans, the game is hard. When upgrading to paid plans of both companies, you can unlock additional discounts, increased stores, and access to more features.

Currently, Printify offers a Premium plan for $29/month and a custom Enterprise plan.
Meanwhile, Gelato provides three options: Gelato for $24/month, Gold for $119/month, and Platinum with custom pricing.

Both companies offer free and paid plans to cater to the different needs of sellers

6. Customer Support

Gelato and Printify strive to provide thoughtful customer support and helpful resources to assist their sellers. Let's examine the details of their customer services.

Available time: Both have 24/7 support.
Response time: Gelato often responds within 8 hours, whereas Printify may take up to 24 hours.
Live chat: Gelato and Printify provide automated live chat for addressing typical queries.
Email support: Email options are available for both companies.
Phone support: Neither Gelato nor Printify offers phone support.
Language: Printify provides support only in English, whereas Gelato supports 10+ languages including English, Spanish, Deutsch, Vietnamese, etc.

7. Customer Reviews

Most customers leave positive reviews for Gelato and Printify, resulting in high rating scores for both companies. However, Printify receives more views on most platforms due to its larger product range compared to Gelato.

Here are the rating comparisons between Gelato vs Printify on three famous platforms, gathered by Teeinblue:

Shopify: Gelato and Printify currently have the same rating of 4.8. However, Printify has over 5.700 reviews, more than eight times the number of Gelato's 650+ reviews.
Trustpilot: Printify maintains a slight edge with a rating of 4.8 from nearly 3.000 reviews. Meanwhile, Gelato achieves a rating of 4.7 from 1.767 reviews.
G2: Both companies have relatively few reviews on this platform. Gelato has a rating of 4.5 from 11 reviews, while Printify has a rating of 4.0 from 13 reviews.

Gelato and Printify receive high scores on review platforms

Is Gelato or Printify Better to Sell Print-on-demand With?

When considering Gelato or Printify, the choice depends on your specific goals. Gelato shines for sellers prioritizing eco-friendly POD products and aiming to tap into the European market. On the other hand, Printify is an ideal choice for those seeking a wide variety of products at more reasonable prices.

Gelato vs printify which is better for your print on demand business

Choosing between Gelato and Printify depends on your specific goals

It's crucial to have a thorough grasp of Gelato vs Printify before reaching a decision. Through an in-depth review of this article, you now have valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each platform. Ready for your journey with print-on-demand, join the Teeinblue Global Community now!